by Alex Duval Smith

Critical levels

Medical school addresses lack of rural doctors

Building a stronger skills base
shortage of rural doctors

A South African medical school has become the first in Africa to address the continent's chronic shortage of rural doctors. 

"The fact is that 43% of South Africans live in rural areas, but only 12% of doctors work there," says Hoffie Conradie, a former rural general practitioner who is director of the University of Stellenbosch's year-old Ukwanda Rural Clinical School.

South Africa has long battled the ever increasing skills shortages and has a critical shortage of doctors. We currently have only 0.57 doctors for every 1 000 people, compared with an average of two to five doctors in developed countries.

Continent-wide, the World Health Organization says 36 countries face a critical shortage of health personnel. Worldwide, recruiting doctors for rural practices is a challenge, and the R65-million ($7.6m, £4.7m) Ukwanda initiative is modelled on schools in Australia and Canada.

Most South African medical students spend their final year between classrooms and city hospital wards. Marcia Vermeulen, 24, has just graduated as one of 20 students who spent their sixth year at Ukwanda.

"It was an eye-opener because we had the unique opportunity to do home visits," she says. "I had an elderly gentleman as a patient. I drew his blood while he lay on his bed in his home. It was humbling to be trusted by the family, and I really gained an insight into the best of what medicine can be – a holistic process with social and socio-economic implications. It was much more meaningful than being in a tertiary institution where you treat the patient as a disease process."

Based 110 kilometres from Cape Town in the town of Worcester, the newly built Ukwanda Rural Clinical School sends some of its final-year students to three rural health districts – where they also live – and others to the town's hospital and day clinics. The area has high levels of alcoholism and drug abuse, as well as a heavy burden of patients being treated for tuberculosis, HIV, hypertension, asthma and diabetes.

To deepen the students' understanding of the causes of disease, each student doctor takes on six 'portfolio patients': care-seekers whom they meet regularly, visit at home and of whom they write full profiles, including details of income and family background.

Nurse and student co-ordinator Helta Jordaan, who is based at a health centre in a shipping container on the outskirts of Worcester, says the process is as useful for the students as it is for the patients. "The students have spotted early cases of malnutrition in children and organised quick referrals to a nutritionist," she says. "They also learn clinical reasoning here: rather than being faced with a broken toe that needs an x-ray, they have to work out what is wrong with an aching toe."

In South Africa, the government's only requirement of its young doctors is that they do a year's community service after their two-year postgraduate internship. As a result, Stellenbosch University has had to turn to the Medical Education Partnership Initiative– a United States programme – for financial support.

Nevertheless, at least three other South African medical schools are planning similar initiatives, Conradie says. He spent most of his career in the rural Eastern Cape – South Africa's poorest province and the one with the lowest density of doctors. 

comments powered by Disqus


This edition

Issue 23


TLConvention We would also like the world to see what young South African leaders are all about, so please remember the event hashtags… 9 months - reply - retweet - favorite

Ubuntumag1 'Hennessy VSOP Privilege Limited Edition' product launch'. #launch #hennessy 0 years - reply - retweet - favorite

TLConvention Opening speaker at #OMTLC, Minister Jeff Radebe recently spoke to - 0 years - reply - retweet - favorite